Quantcast
Click here to read more...
March 27, 2008
Newsletter:     
Search:        
 
Click Here to Order!
 
Return to Home Page Return to Old Archive Home Page Doctrine, Scripture, Morality, Vocation, Community Identity, Sexuality, Family, Healing, Work Art, Ideas, Technology, Science, Business Politics, Bioethics, Ecology, Justice, Peace Spirituality, Prayers, Poems, and Witness Archive of top news from around the web Columns, Reviews and Personal Essays What is Godspy?
faith article
spacer
spacer
<OPINION>
RELATED LINKS
Casa Juan Diego
"Casa Juan Diego was founded in 1980, following the Catholic Worker model, to serve immigrants and refugees. From one small house it has grown to fifteen houses. Casa Juan Diego publishes a newspaper, the 'Houston Catholic Worker', to share the stories of the immigrants and refugees and the values of the Catholic Worker movement."

I Am Pontius Pilate
Like Pontius Pilate in The Passion, my hands aren’t clean. Although I see myself as nice, as harmless, as a good girl, I am brimming full of sin.

Kill Jesus Vol I?
Filmgoers reared on the extreme cinematic violence of Tarantino, Scorcese and even Gibson are flocking to The Passion, drawn to the brutal reality of Jesus’ death. But do buckets of blood drown the meaning of the sacrifice?

Sister Peter Claver Spent Life Working for Poor and Forgotten by Rosemary Fielding
A fledgling ballerina in New York City, 20 year old Hannah Fahy asked God to make her life worthwhile. She spent the rest of her 105 years as Sister Peter Claver, ministering to prisoners.

The Unbearable Reality of Love: The Passion of The Christ, by John Zmirak
In this film we see with unbearable clarity how Jesus descended into the personal Hell each of us carries around - and purged it clean.

Two Zen Men and a Christian at the Passion
My friends Gene and Hamilton are fiercely honest spiritual seekers. As we watched The Passion together in silence, I knew they would allow their hearts to be rent by the torture and killing of this man called The Christ.

ADVERTISEMENTS
Click here to buy the movie...
 
 
 
 
 
 
Click here to see the video!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Click here to buy!
 
 
 
Click Here to Order!
 
 
 
Click here to buy!
 
 
 
 
 
 

Violence, The Passion and the Blood of the Poor

We were hesitant to see "The Passion of the Christ" after hearing about the violence, since our lives are filled with violence. We were quite surprised by our reaction.

The Passion of the Christ
We avoided seeing "The Passion," not by choice but by life style. We have not been in a movie theater in a number of years, though we have dropped off our grandchildren with their mother, all of whom who live with us, at the movies a number of times, which helps the kids to keep up with the Joneses. It helps to bring them to normalcy and belonging as far as their peers are concerned, which is helpful since they are being raised in a different kind of environment than most children. We are surrounded by poor immigrants and Catholic Workers and lead sheltered lives.

The grandkids are Tolkien specialists and have been exposed to this profound religious writer, which can only be helpful. There is more violence than we are comfortable with, however in the Tolkien movies, even though it is often directed at orcs.

We were hesitant to see "The Passion of the Christ" after hearing about the violence, since our lives are filled with violence which we hate to face and refuse to integrate for fear of abandoning our work with immigrants altogether. We have our own bloody Jesus that can match anything Mel Gibson and the makeup artists can create—it is the blood of the immigrants. It is Jesus suffering in the poor.

We have experienced the Passion of Jesus in his poor, but no movie reviewer has ever called these sufferings pornographic or obscene.
The journey of the immigrant is the way of the Cross, where there are various stations of suffering along the way: crossing the Suchiate River at the border of Guatemala and Mexico, what happens after they arrive in Mexico, the crossing of the Rio Grande River, where violence overflows on both sides. Immigrants who die in the river or in the beastly hot desert don't complete the way of the cross.

How often have we seen bloodied and black and blue faces of the robbed immigrant. How often have we seen people with busted jaws and broken teeth, eyes totally shut as bad as the Roman soldiers would do to Jesus. How often have we seen people with no nails in their feet—they had no feet because their legs were cut off when they jumped off a train, or with legs totally paralyzed by a gunshot in the back, when nails would not make a difference in dead legs.

How often we have seen immigrants full of knife wounds or opened up from the neck to below the navel because of the doctors' fear of internal injuries. They have been attacked because thieves thought they were carrying all the money they had earned because they couldn't get a bank account.

We have experienced the Passion of Jesus in his poor, but no movie reviewer has ever called these sufferings pornographic or obscene. They are obscene as hell!

The movie reviewers convinced us not to see "The Passion". They said it was too violent, in fact, said it was obscene and pornographic.

Other reviewers said that the movie did not replicate the Gospels word for word and was not orthodox Catholic teaching, nor was Mel Gibson orthodox, for that matter. Some complained that it did not include the very latest in critical scholarship of the Bible.

Hollywood, 'shocked' by the violence of this film, was actually shocked by its message.
Hollywood was upset and appeared to believe that it was unethical to make a film that would portray the Gospel as very serious and credible, with Christ as the victim of a cruel injustice. John Mallon has pointed out that there has never been a film portraying Jesus and the Gospels this way. Hollywood, "shocked" by the violence of this film, was actually shocked by the message of the film.

The more we were discouraged from seeing the movie, the more people kept talking about "The Passion", especially among minorities: African-Americans and Hispanics. Many who spoke to us loved the film and were deeply moved. They talked about The Passion openly and while on the job, even though they worked for the government. Apparently, they knew or have experienced the Passion in their lives and had to talk about it, even though they were violating Church and State.

The pressure was on. "Did we see The Passion?" Finally, our high school granddaughter insisted on seeing the movie and on a Sunday morning, we entered the passion play. We approached the movie with some fear and trepidation—like going to a painful dental appointment. Were we masochists?

To beat it all, the movie theater was 45 minutes late in opening and getting started, so we were wasting valuable time at this location we should not have come to in the first place. We should have been at home working on the correspondence.

Our Reaction

Mel Gibson merely took us through the Catholic devotion of the Way of the Cross, depicted on the walls of every Catholic church in the world.
We were quite surprised at our reaction. Suffering and violence, yes, but Mel Gibson merely took us through the Catholic devotion of the Way of the Cross, the fourteen stations, depicted on the walls of every Catholic church in the world. These stations are meditated upon during Lent in all Catholic churches. We were not surprised to see the film bring alive the five sorrowful mysteries of the Rosary: the Agony in the Garden, the Scourging at the Pillar, the Crowning with Thorns, the Carrying of the Cross, and the Crucifixion. There were a few additions from the imaginations of people who had meditated on the Passion over the centuries, which critics used to denigrate the film.

The frosting on the cake of this Catholic experience was the Blessed Mother, who kept showing up like she does in Catholicism and in Sacred Scripture. How can we explain Mother Mary? To those who don't believe, no explanation is possible, to those who believe no explanation is necessary.

It took the movie to help us to realize how steeped in the Passion are our Catholic lives. The cross is omnipresent. If you think about it, everywhere you turn you see Jesus the Nazarene hanging on a tree—on the Cross. The cross can be found in every Catholic church, every Catholic home, and in every room of some institutions. Even some Catholic universities have crosses in their classrooms. It wasn't too long ago that you could tell the difference between a Catholic church and a Protestant church by the cross on the top of the Catholic Church. Catholic prayers always begin with the Sign of the Cross. Even boxers begin their bouts with the sign.

Some wear a cross around their neck to show that they are ready to give their lives for others as Jesus did. This is what the cross means—to give and not to take, to give our lives. The cross as jewelry, however, can be gaudy and obscene.

The Jesus in "The Passion" certainly is more true to the Gospels than the Jesus as a playground supervisor that has emerged in catechetics since Vatican II.

Fr. Hugo, who gave the retreat Dorothy Day attended and promoted, reminded us, as did Mel Gibson, that the Cross has very serious implications for the life of every Christian:

The Jesus in 'The Passion' is more true to the Gospels than the Jesus as a playground supervisor that has emerged in catechetics since Vatican II.
"Radical Christianity is discovered only at the cross, but who desires to be crucified? Like Peter and the other apostles—before the coming of the Holy Spirit!—we all tend to prefer a Christianity without the cross, 'air-foam Christianity,' as it was satirized by Ed Willock in Integrity magazine in an outrageous cartoon showing a contented Catholic snuggled down on a cross spread with that seductive cushioning. Many attempt a life of vigorous and dedicated action, while failing to realize that such action is authentically Christian and efficacious only when grafted to the Tree of Life on Calvary."

Jesus gave his life for others, for each of us. Salvation is not only personal, but has implications for social responsibility. Jesus told us in Matthew 25 that on Judgment Day we would be judged on love, on whether we care for him and serve him in the poor.

We'd better get busy. Pray for us.

spacer
May 18, 2004

MARK AND LOUISE ZWICK run Casa Juan Diego, which aids immigrants and refugees, and the Houston Catholic Worker newspaper, from which this article was reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.

Email A Friend
READER COMMENTS
05.18.04   alexander caughey says:
With all the will in the world, what could we expect from a picture that expected us to react, exactly as we reacted. That the whole event was orchestrated from start to finish with the polish of Hollywood, despite the apparent negative reaction of a Hollywood, unaccustomed to the reaction that we poor appreciators of violence could expect to experience, when confronted with the appearance of so much blood and torture. The whole event was an experience of whole sale theatre of compulsive viewing, meant to convince us that the spectacle was real, when in reality it was staged. Hip Hip Hooray.What a display of mindless clap trap, what nausea, what hog wash. Can one really expect to be transformed by such a display of over hyped dramatic indifference to the real needs of suffering humanity. When will we ever learn? Christ's death, has always been about our suffering, as the human race. Christ has no ego. The Passion of The Christ, is about the suffering human being.Who cares when we munch another hamburger? Do we care? Do we really care? Or do we stuff five dollars down another collecting can, belonging to Christian Aid? Can we ever experience the feelings, the reactions, the unbelievable misery of another human being, living in The Sudan? Try Zimbabwe; Try North Korea; Try Iraq. Do we really care beyond that five dollars and that emotional experience?Will this film of suffering goad us into really caring for the misery that surrounds us in the United States.Will we sacrifice all, for those in real need? Not bloody likely. For we have our own life to pay for.We appear at Mass, every Sunday, and carry out our robotic duties, only to disappear to our brunch and life of plenty. I know, for I am you in all that we do and care not for those whose daily sacrifice is but that which we have experienced, when viewing The Passion of The Christ. Enough of this twaddle.It is a film, meant to exploit our deepest feelings of remorse for not doing enough for our fellow man, and this is where the film will succeed, if only we could appreciate that their, in that miserable state of helplessness, lies us, lying in a hospital, a hospice, a run-down apartment block, an alleyway. That we choose to be moved and then - nothing - just emotion and fine words of appreciation. When did we last spend an afternoon, working for love, in a soup kitchen, in a hospice, in a homeless sheleter?Emotional responses to this film, should best be translated into real responses, in love and not in empty experiences of tears of emptiness. Who do we kid, when we cry for the screen Christ; for the needy?Not bloody likely. We're too busy. Let them get on with their failure to live successfully. We have a mortage,repayment plan, an insurance policy, an attitude of indifference. Welcome to success till failure comes knocking on our door. This film can teach us to appreciate that life's little miseries, can also affect us, when we are all so indifferent to each others needs. That our problems are solvable, when those who are in plenty, contribute to those in need, might well dispel the problem of those in need and those who are in need, in waiting.

05.18.04   Jonathan Kinsman says:
How refreshing and new! Like the Gospel heard and understood for the first time! An epiphany for us 'soft' Catholics! The Zwicks have made my week!Forget the extraneous chatter of Gibson's directorial choices or non-choices; forget the specious blather about words spoken ("His blood upon us!") but not subtitled; forget the silly hand wringing on Pilate's portrayal: focus on the Crucifix.The Zwicks (May God continue to bless them and the work they do) have done us a service. They have put in straightforward prose the real effect of the visually stunning "The Passion of the Christ." It is to take on the suffering of the poor and misfortunate of our society. We need to (spiritually) bleed and suffer for those less fortunate than us. We need to witness EVERY DAY the message of the Crucifixion: work to prevent the daily, petty (to us and our concern) sufferings and indignities to our brothers and sisters. As long as we look for the epic and the photo-op, we will continue to ignore the "leper" in the road, or the laborer in the field. Use our parishes as "upper rooms!" Break bread with strangers: use the strength given by our Lord in his Death and Resurrection to change your neighborhood, your town, your state.The joy of Wisdom is in the irony of our Christian life: lose your life to gain it; what you do or fail to do to the least of your brethren, you do or fail to do to Me.The Zwicks have used that sharp and keen weapon of irony to nail the point straight to our lazy, think-about-it hearts. A fine article.God bless you two.

05.18.04   Godspy says:
We were hesitant to see "The Passion of the Christ" after hearing about the violence, since our lives are filled with violence. We were quite surprised by our reaction.

Click to buy at Amazon.com!
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | About Us