Quantcast
Click here to read more...
March 27, 2008
Newsletter:     
Search:        
 
Click Here to Order!
 
Return to Home Page Return to Old Archive Home Page Doctrine, Scripture, Morality, Vocation, Community Identity, Sexuality, Family, Healing, Work Art, Ideas, Technology, Science, Business Politics, Bioethics, Ecology, Justice, Peace Spirituality, Prayers, Poems, and Witness Archive of top news from around the web Columns, Reviews and Personal Essays What is Godspy?
faith article
spacer
spacer
<OPINION>
RELATED LINKS
Christianity and Gnosticism A Conflict About Method, by Lorenzo Albacete
In the Incarnation, salvation springs from the earth, from human flesh, from the very body despised by the Gnostics of The Da Vinci Code.

Faith, Politics and the Scandal of Christ, by Msgr Lorenzo Albacete
The national chaplain for the international Catholic lay movement 'Communion and Liberation' explains their 2004 election statement: 'A Call to Freedom,' and why Jesus Christ is the answer to the problem of religion and politics.

The Cry of Suffering, by Lorenzo Albacete
The redemption of suffering cannot be found as an "ultimate answer" to a problem: it can only be an event that transforms the drama of suffering into a drama of love and shows love to be more powerful than its denial.

The Evidence of the Resurrection, by Lorenzo Albacete
What will convince the world about Jesus is the way we love one another. A capacity to love that would be impossible if Jesus had not conquered death.

To Build the Church, by Lorenzo Albacete
Our task is not a cultural battle as such, even if others see it that way and struggle against us and we must resist. Our task is to build the Church.

ADVERTISEMENTS
Click here to buy the movie...
 
 
 
 
 
 
Click here to see the video!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Click here to buy!
 
 
 
Click Here to Order!
 
 
 
Click here to buy!
 
 
 
 
 
 

Neo-Darwinism & Intelligent Design: A Question of Reason

From a Catholic perspective, the ability of reason to grasp an intelligent design behind reality doesn't depend on the limited perspective of scientific inquiry.


Many have asked me to comment on the debate concerning the ability of science to detect an
"intelligent design" in its study of nature, particularly the evolution of the species culminating in man. Religious conservatives (mostly Protestant Evangelicals and some Catholics) are insisting that the "scientific" view of "intelligent design" be taught to students in public school. This is, of course, being resisted by those who see it as an intrusion of religion into the public school curriculum, as well as by those who appeal to science to justify a cultural agenda hostile to faith.

Reason does not clash with faith, provided we do not equate reason to the method of scientific inquiry.
The debate on intelligent design in the United States is thus more a political struggle than a scientific or religious debate. It originates in the efforts of Protestant Christian believers to resist the political power of the radical secularists who appeal to neo-Darwinism to justify their political policies.
It would seem that, at least theoretically, Protestant fideism would not care about what science holds or does not hold, since for fideists faith and reason are split. But what to do when an anti-faith ideology with a cultural agenda gains political power and appeals to science to support its view of what it means to be human?

"Intelligent Design" is an attempt to respond to this cultural challenge. It represents an attempt to reconcile science with the Protestant view of faith and in some way escape from the limitations of fideism. Ironically, this response surrenders too much to science by letting science be the norm of what is ultimately affirmed as the ultimate, defining truth about man's origin and destiny.

But what to do when an anti-faith ideology with a cultural agenda gains political power and appeals to science to support its view of what it means to be human?
The Catholic approach to this issue starts from a completely different point. Catholics insist that there is no opposition between properly understood views of faith and reason. Reason does not clash with faith, provided we do not equate reason with the method of scientific inquiry. The scientific method is a particular application of reason that seeks to understand the relations of causality between events that are purely material and measurable. The spiritual or non-material dimension is excluded from this method from the very beginning of the inquiry.

Reason, whose power lies in its openness to the totality of all the factors that constitute reality, is thus restricted in its scope. An event or a series of events examined from this limited perspective will show no evidence of intelligent design, since intelligent design betokens freedom and purpose. The Catholic affirmation of the ability of reason to grasp an intelligent design behind reality does not depend on the results of such a scientific method. We do not require that science, understood this way, show evidence of intelligent design in order to affirm that a reasonable gaze at reality points to design or purpose and providence.

The current debate is framed within a view of reason that is not our view. Reason can grasp intelligence behind reality, but our Catholic faith grasps Love as the ultimate ground of all that exists and man as the creature created to respond freely to that creative Love as the "self-consciousness of the universe," so to speak. However, it is not to science that we appeal to make this affirmation, but to reason enlightened by faith.

spacer
January 26, 2006

MSGR. LORENZO ALBACETE is National Director of the ecclesial movement Communion & Liberation.

This article originally appeared in the Italian magazine Tempi, No. 29, 9/22/05. The english translation was originally published in Traces, the magazine of Communion & Liberation. Reprinted with permission of the author. ©2005, Lorenzo Albacete. All rights reserved.

Email A Friend
READER COMMENTS
01.26.06   Godspy says:
From a Catholic perspective, the ability of reason to grasp an intelligent design behind reality doesn't depend on the limited perspective of scientific inquiry.

Click to buy at Amazon.com!
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | About Us